dBA, bels and dB do not convert
WD publishes dBA and marks its Blue figures as sound power. Seagate publishes dBA on newer data sheets and bels of sound power, typical and max, in its product manuals. Toshiba publishes dB for idle only, without saying which quantity it measured.
Seagate supplies the proof that these cannot be mixed. For the IronWolf 4TB ST4000VN006, data sheet DS1904.22 from 2024 gave 27 dBA seek, the 2025 edition DS1904.23 gives 25, and the product manual gives 2.5 bels. That is one maker, one drive and three figures, no two of which match. If Seagate's own documents cannot be converted into each other, figures from different makers in different units cannot be either.
So each unit is ranked on its own and never converted. Why a drive's idle figure in bels is not a dBA reading is spelled out in our page on sound power and sound pressure, and every current Seagate family is sorted by unit on our Seagate hard drive page.
What is the quietest hard drive?
A small, slow one. WD's 2.5 inch Blue mobile rates 19 idle and 21 seek at 1TB, and Seagate's BarraCuda 2.5 rates 2.0 and 2.2 bels at the same capacity, both at 5400 RPM.
Among 3.5 inch drives on WD's sheets:
| Drive | RPM | Idle | Seek |
|---|
| WD Blue WD10EARZ, 1TB | 5400 | 21 dBA | 26 dBA |
| WD Red Plus, 4TB | 5400 | 23 dBA | 27 dBA |
| WD Red Pro and Gold, 8TB | 7200 | 29 dBA | 36 dBA |
Seagate's current IronWolf sheet starts lower, at 20 idle and 21 seek for the 2TB ST2000VN003, but we could not find that model number new on Amazon. Our WD hard drive page lists every current WD capacity.
WD's Red Plus rates 21 idle at 2TB and 34 at 10TB. That is a bigger swing than the gap between most families.
Seagate's current IronWolf sheet climbs from 20 dBA idle at 2TB to 28 at 10TB and above. Then the trend reverses for helium. Toshiba's N300 and X300 rate 34 dB idle at 10TB and under and 20 dB from 12TB up, and Seagate's IronWolf Pro drops from 28 dBA idle on its air-filled models to 20 on its helium ones. Neither maker explains why. For anyone who needs large drives, though, the biggest capacities are often the quietest at idle.
Read the figure for the exact model number you are buying.
Prebuilt desktops are declared as a whole machine, and our desktop PC guide shows how disk and optical drive modes appear in those declarations.
Which quiet HDD should go in a NAS?
A 5400 RPM CMR drive: WD's Red Plus 4TB at 23 dBA idle and 27 seek, or Seagate's IronWolf 8TB at 25 and 26.
Neither maker says whether those NAS figures are sound power or sound pressure, so the two sit side by side without one maker ranked above the other. Seagate's IronWolf 4TB rates 23 and 25 on the current sheet, but Amazon had it out of stock on November 8.
The two quietest drives here use SMR recording. That suits a single laptop or backup drive and performs poorly when a NAS rebuilds an array. Our NAS guide covers the enclosures.
Data sheets that leave noise out
Seagate's 3.5 inch BarraCuda, SkyHawk and Exos data sheets have no acoustics row, and their figures live only in the product manuals. Toshiba publishes no seek figure for any consumer drive, and its P300 appears only on its European site. WD names no measuring standard except on its Blue sheets.
None of this changes the ranking. It does explain why some drives are documented more fully than others.